Oasis

seanc80

Wasn’t a fan at all. Thought their song writing was childlike and really over did the arrogance to the point where it was a '‘show’. Liam as a frontman was top drawer though in fairness.

I just thought that other bands of a similar ilk were far more talented and more interesting, such as Stone Roses, Verve Richrad Ashcroft (post-Verve)

baggers44

seanc80 first Verve album is v underrated

Along_the_Wire

I’ll give them Definitely Maybe, the rest, apart from a handful of b-sides, is absolute tripe.

Along_the_Wire

Ed, you forgot your low hanging fruit tab.

Smallman1

Along_the_Wire Ed, you forgot your low hanging fruit tab.

Lol, thought I’d snuck it in under the radar!

Along_the_Wire

Is this the thread where I tell the story about watching them to Top of Pops with Live Forever and then jump on the Northern Line to The Astoria to see them live in the same clothes. One of the most electric, atmospheric gigs I’ve ever been to. I went on my own as I could only get one single ticket.

alistair

Along_the_Wire yet you still think What’s the Story is shit. 30m albums later…

Millsy

Ed is blatantly more a Blur man surely?

Smallman1

Millsy Ed is blatantly more a Blur man surely?

Madness.

As in the band not the suggestion that I’m more of a Blur man.

bosstrabs

To be fair, when did record sales denote quality?

bosstrabs

IMO Morning Glory is an absolutely scandalous act of plagiarism, I’m surprised they only had to remove one track.

alistair

bosstrabs so what? every band/act has begged, stolen or borrowed to a degree. Nile Rodgers is still waiting to be paid by every rapper that has ripped off Chic

Smallman1

hugopal They’re absolute gash, of course smalls likes them.

Suspect you’re more of a Cabaret Voltaire man aren’t you Hugo?

Of course you are you absolute clown.

hugopal

Smallman1 I once went to a house party at the house of the trumpeter. Trufax.

And yes it was in the middle of their street.

alistair

The likes of Champagne Supernova, Morning Glory, Some might say, Don’t look back in anger and Wonderwall may be ubquitous and overplayed but are a million miles away from being shit. 99% of bands would have given their right arm to have written just one of them. Songs that will stand the test of time.

Heno

Seen them when Morning Glory just came out in The Point in Dublin and it was unreal proper crest of a wave stuff they filled a void in music and got a lot of people at the right age and stuff as soon as the members all start leaving they became a Beatles tribute band

Smallman1

A lol for Hugo, his first ever one too!

Cap doffed!

-si-

Is anyone going to stick their head above the pulpit and try to call champagne supernova shit?

I thought not!

bosstrabs

Champagne Supernova was good. Stay Young was another excellent b-side.

They were at their best when not just blatantly ripping off the Beatles or T-Rex and actually bothered to use their imagination/songwriting ability a bit.

-si-

I think they have an unreal back catalogue, it’s a pity they seem to turn into complete weapons when paired with one another. Definitely bring out the worst in the other. They can’t half write a record though.

alistair

-si- quite liked Noel’s last album with David Holmes on production duties, there were three or four really good songs on it

Smallman1

By they you mean Noel right?

« Previous Page Next Page »