• [deleted]

  • Edited

hugopal

It “failed”?! It did too well to be labelled a failure.

Absolutely, everyone stopped making it after around 2001, and quickly jumped ship to tech house and mnml when they realised they were just making [paul van dyk without breakdowns. The Dutch and German cheese merchants had more integrity in this regard than the south coast numpties.

    • [deleted]

    hugopal

    This is wrong, but again, not sure what it has to do with anything anyway.

    No UFOs, Big Fun, and Good Life would like a word!

      • [deleted]

      • [deleted]

      [deleted] No UFOs, Big Fun, and Good Life would like a word!

      No UFOs is as much an electro tune.

      Big Fun and Good Life always sounded as much house as techno (I’ve had that discussion on here before - Saunderson was always the least ‘techno’/most house sounding of the Belleville Three and had more of an NY influence to his sound than the others).I also find Good Life a bit cringe, while Big Fun is touch and go.

      However you spin it, I don’t see how they can be labelled “the best techno”.

        • [deleted]

        hugopal cubic 22 - night in motion.
        Ravesignal 3 - Horsepower.
        Praga Khan - Injected with a Poison.

          [deleted] Absolutely, everyone stopped making it after around 2001, and quickly jumped ship to tech house and mnml when they realised they were just making [paul van dyk without breakdowns.

          Everyone stopped making disco at the start of the 80s, doesn’t mean it had “failed” either.

          Tech house and minimal also both died much quicker than prog had when people realised they were just making dull music.

          “Paul van Dyk without breakdowns” isn’t really a diss either, PvD had some excellent moments in the 90s. Long breakdowns also get in the way of dancing, while supposedly you are claiming to be an advocate of ‘dance’ music.

          [deleted] The Dutch and German cheese merchants had more integrity in this regard than the south coast numpties.

          The Dutch and German cheese merchants briefly jumped on the electroclash fad as well, before mostly abandoning any kind of dancefloor sensibility in the pursuit of pop crossovers / radio play, together with generic stadium filler. Don’t see how that has any more to do with “integrity”.

            I haven’t listened to any of them but i imagine some of those garage videos to be real treats for the ears

              seanc80 lol at you giving them the time of day. I see Dave or Alistair post a YT music clip, I S to the werve, big time.

              • [deleted]

              mike ink and walker - Church of the Poisoned Mind

              which is obvs a reference to this.

              [deleted] that Praga Khan track is cheese.

              Ravesignal 3 is good but sounds both the most ‘techno’ and the least ‘pop’ of the lot.

                • [deleted]

                • Edited

                hugopal

                Everyone stopped making disco at the start of the 80s, doesn’t mean it had “failed” either.

                No they didn’t.

                • [deleted]

                hugopal

                The Dutch and German cheese merchants briefly jumped on the electroclash fad as well, before mostly abandoning any kind of dancefloor sensibility in the pursuit of pop crossovers / radio play, together with generic stadium filler. Don’t see how that has any more to do with “integrity”.

                Exactly! thanks for proving my point. They were pop, and logically followed the path they embarked on.

                  • [deleted]

                  • Edited

                  hugopal

                  “Paul van Dyk without breakdowns” isn’t really a diss either, PvD had some excellent moments in the 90s.

                  No he didn’t, music strictly for EDL goons. But still preferable to centrist long kesh stronger prog house types because he was at least honest.

                    • [deleted]

                    hugopal

                    Tech house and minimal also both died much quicker than prog had when people realised they were just making dull music.

                    Is that why Digweed still plays kompakt, Pig and Dan, etc whilst he will never play all the Armin Van Buuren and Transa Dross he was playing in ’97? Great argument my main man!

                      • [deleted]

                      hugopal

                      Ravesignal 3 is good but sounds both the most ‘techno’ and the least ‘pop’ of the lot.

                      well, it got played on daytime radio, along with quadrophenia.

                      The same can’t be said for West on 27th.

                        • [deleted]

                        Along_the_Wire it’s ok boss, I have your divorce nicely arranged. You’ll soon be a contented man, suffering much less from old man butthurt syndrome. Just give it a week.